Teachers play the biggest role in how well students do in school. The U.S. spent a huge $192 billion in 2002 on teachers’ pay and benefits. Even with this large investment, there’s not enough solid research to help choose, keep, and boost teachers. This study looks at different aspects of teachers to see what makes them more effective. The goal is to help make better choices in education policy.
This research looks at five main areas to measure how good teachers are: their experience, education, teaching certification, the classes they took, and their test scores. Studying these key parts helps policy makers understand what makes a teacher great. They can then make decisions that lead to better teaching in the classroom.
Key Takeaways
- Teacher quality is the most important school-related factor influencing student achievement.
- The United States invested $192 billion in teacher pay and benefits in 2002 alone, highlighting the significant public investment in education.
- There is a lack of robust research to guide critical decisions regarding teacher hiring, retention, and promotion.
- The study examines five key indicators of teacher quality: experience, preparation programs, certification, coursework, and test scores.
- Analyzing the impact of these factors can inform education policy decisions and improve teaching effectiveness.
Introduction: The Policy and Research Context
Education is shaped by many resources, with teachers at its core. There is disagreement on what makes a good teacher. This leads to varied policies on teacher training, standards, and more.
Teacher Quality: A Pivotal Policy Issue
Over half of a school’s budget goes to teacher pay. Understanding what makes a strong teacher is vital. This is shown by the huge amount spent on teachers in 2002 in the U.S.
Factors Influencing Teacher Policy Decisions
Things like a teacher’s experience and their degrees matter a lot. Studies on teachers’ abilities play a big role in deciding who should teach. Understanding these issues helps in making better choices.
Teacher Experience and Effectiveness
Research shows that how long a teacher has been working affects how well they teach. They learn more and improve by teaching. New teachers are not as good as experienced ones.
After about twenty years, teachers are very skilled. They help students learn better, especially in math. But, being a great teacher can slow down after 25 years. This is especially true in high school.
It’s important to keep good teachers and help them grow. Doing this improves how well students do in school. But, we need to make sure all schools have great teachers. This means making sure poor schools get the good ones too.
Teacher Preparation Programs and Degrees
A teacher’s education and training quality really matter for student success, especially in high school. Studies show that where a teacher goes to school influences how well they teach. This is likely because smarter teachers can guide students better.
Institutional Selectivity and Prestige
The selectivity of a teacher’s school predicts how well their students will do, especially in high school. Graduates of top schools might be better teachers. This is because their high-quality education aids in their teaching effectiveness.
Impact of Advanced Degrees
Getting advanced degrees in the subjects they teach helps teachers, especially in high schools. For math and science teachers, these degrees lead to better student achievement. But, the benefit of more degrees for elementary teachers isn’t as clear.
Measure | Findings |
---|---|
Institutional Selectivity | Teachers from more selective and prestigious institutions tend to be more effective, particularly at the secondary level. |
Advanced Degrees | Teachers with advanced degrees in their subject areas have a positive impact on high school student achievement in those subjects, but the evidence is less clear at the elementary level. |
The Impact of Education Policies on Teaching Quality
The first source shows how important teacher qualities are. This includes knowledge of teaching and the subject, their credentials, experience, and test scores. It’s been found that getting rid of all credentialing requirements is not the best move. But, just sticking to the old ways won’t help improve teacher quality either. So, policies need to consider that teaching is a complex process. It’s influenced by many parts of what makes a good teacher.
There’s also a call to fill gaps in knowledge about teacher quality. Especially at the elementary and middle school levels, in subjects not math, and for different student groups. Decision-makers need a better grasp of what makes teaching effective. This includes looking at every grade, subject, and type of student to make teaching better for everyone.
Key Factors Influencing Teaching Quality | Findings from the Literature |
---|---|
Teacher Preparation Programs and Degrees | Research shows that where a teacher went to school impacts how well students do, especially in high school. Teachers with advanced degrees in their subject, like math and science, also boost their students’ success. |
Teacher Certification and Experience | In math, having a certification improves how well students do in high school. Yet, alternative paths like emergency certifications don’t show the same impact. Teaching gets better with experience, especially at the start, reinforcing the “learning by doing” idea. |
Teacher Coursework and Test Scores | The subjects and how to teach them that teachers have studied matter for student success. Teacher’s literacy and verbal skills have been linked to how well their students do. But, general tests for teaching skills are not as good at predicting success for students. |
An extreme centralized control or letting go of all regulations on teachers won’t work. A balanced, refined approach is more hopeful. It focuses on improving policies to have well-qualified teachers for all students and subjects.
“Investing in teachers can make a difference in student achievement, and substantial and targeted investments must be made in both teacher quality and education research to implement needed policies for staffing every classroom with high-quality teachers.”
Addressing many parts of teacher quality helps leaders create better strategies. This in turn boosts The Impact of Education Policies on Teaching Quality and improves how well students do in school.
Teacher Certification and Student Achievement
Studies show having a math certification helps high school teachers boost student success. Certified teachers in mathematics help students do better than uncertified teachers. But the effect of alternative-route certification programs isn’t as clear.
Certified Teachers in Mathematics
A 1995-2002 study in Houston, Texas proved math-certified teachers support student success more than uncertified teachers. This highlights why having a certification in key subjects is important. Knowing the subject well helps students learn better.
Alternative-Route Certification
On the other hand, emergency or alternative-route certification programs might not help much in math or science. Research found that uncertified Teach for America (TFA) recruits were not as good as certified teachers. Even if the uncertified TFA teachers later got their certification, their effectiveness was limited by leaving within three years.
Having a teacher certification is key, especially in important subjects. It helps students achieve more. Relying only on alternative programs isn’t the best way to fill the need for teachers. So, teacher certification is crucial for student success.
Importance of Teacher Coursework
Research shows how crucial teacher coursework is for student success. Teacher coursework, both in subject area taught and pedagogy, helps students do better. Especially, when teachers know how to teach and what to teach, student success goes up. This proves that teachers need a mix of content knowledge and pedagogical skills to be the best at their jobs.
Content Knowledge and Pedagogy
At high schools, content knowledge is key because students learn complex subjects. So, making sure high school teachers know their subject very well can help students a lot. But, knowing how to teach also matters. Research says pedagogical coursework makes teachers better no matter what grade they teach. This tells us teacher training should cover both what to teach and how to teach it well.
Field Experience Component
Looking at how field experience affects teaching, studies find it helps prepare future teachers. While it’s not clear if it directly causes better teaching, field experience helps new teachers feel more ready. It’s clear that adding real-world teaching opportunities to teacher training can make a big difference.
Key Takeaways | Findings |
---|---|
Teacher Coursework | Coursework in both the subject area taught and pedagogy contributes to positive educational outcomes. |
Pedagogical Coursework | Pedagogical coursework helps teachers at all grade levels, especially with content knowledge. |
Content Coursework | At high schools, content coursework is extremely important. |
Field Experience | Experiences in the field help new teachers learn and feel less stressed. |
Teachers’ Test Scores and Student Achievement
Studies show that when teachers score well on literacy or verbal tests, students do better. This means teachers who are good at reading and writing can help students learn more. So, teachers’ own skills can really boost what their students achieve.
But, some exams like the National Teachers Examination don’t always predict how well a teacher will do in the classroom. This tells us it’s hard to use just one test score to see if a teacher is good. We need a broader way to check if teachers are really helping students learn.
Literacy and Verbal Abilities
Tests that check how well teachers can read and communicate connect to student success. These tests suggest teachers who are strong in these skills can teach better. As a result, student learning in reading, writing, and other areas may improve.
Yet, looking only at test scores, we don’t see everything that makes a teacher effective. Teaching is complex. It involves more than just being smart in some subjects. We need to consider skills like managing a classroom, how they teach, and what they know about the subjects they teach. This gives a better view of how good a teacher really is for their students.
Balancing Teacher Requirements and Deregulation
In the effort to uplift teacher quality, policymakers face a tough challenge. They need to find the right mix between strict teacher requirements and the good side of deregulation. Studies show that going too far in either direction is not smart. It’s about finding a middle ground.
Refining Policies for Qualified Teachers
Improving policies and practices shows a lot of potential. This is especially true for making sure there are great teachers in all kinds of schools. This includes those for kids with different needs and backgrounds. Making policies that fit different school and student situations is key. It helps put good teachers in every class, pushing students to do their best.
Investing in Teacher Quality and Research
Studies clearly show that better teachers lead to better student success. This means we need to put more money and focus on teacher quality and education research. Doing this allows for setting up important policies. These policies work to ensure every class has top-notch teachers. By improving policies and spending more on teacher quality and research, leaders can help form a strong teaching team. This team will be ready to meet all students’ needs.
Addressing Overcrowding in Schools
Overcrowding is a big problem in schools. Around 14% of schools in the U.S. have too many students. This issue hits low-income and minority kids the most. When classes are too full, it’s harder for teachers to help everyone effectively. Students also struggle to get the attention they need. This leads to more stress for both students and teachers.
Effects of Overcrowded Classrooms
Too many students hurt how well kids learn and cope with stress. The 2015 PISA study showed the U.S. dropped to 35th place in math. This was an 11-point drop, leaving the U.S. 20 points below the OECD average. It’s clear that overcrowding hurts how well students do in school.
Policy Strategies for Managing Capacity
There are many ways policymakers can tackle overcrowding. They can make detailed plans to avoid it. They could also set up special groups to watch over school sizes. It’s essential to keep the balance in class sizes. This helps create better learning environments for students and teachers.
Statistic | Value |
---|---|
Average ratio of pupils to teachers in the 50 states (2013-2014) | Shown in the chart above |
States with laws requiring a ratio of 20 students or less per teacher | 12 |
Projected increase in public school enrollment by 2024-2025 | 6%, with Nevada experiencing a 26% increase and West Virginia a decline of 11% |
Link between school budget decreases and increasing student numbers | Importance of keeping class sizes from becoming too large to positively affect teacher job satisfaction and student achievement |
Class size average in 2016 | 15 students in public schools, 12.2 students in private schools |
States actively promoting or requiring a reduction in class size (2011) | 24 |
Cost of changing the national class size average by one student | $12 billion per year in teacher salaries |
Impact of smaller class size on early learning and cognitive studies | Substantial improvement found in a study in Tennessee |
Outcomes for students from smaller classes in the Tennessee study | Higher on-time graduation rates, more advanced math and English course completion, lower dropout rates, and more honors graduates |
Prioritizing School Funding and Teacher Support
The second source’s stats show a tough school funding scene in the U.S. Only 44% of education money comes from the states. This means many states give less money per student than they used to, pre-recession.
Many states put more money into prison housing than into student education. To fix this, we should focus on school funding and teacher support. One good idea is to change how we tax to bring in more money for schools. This would show the big economic impact of having great schools and well-paid teachers.
It’s crucial to give more money, especially in poor areas. This will help bring in and keep top-quality teachers. These teachers make students do better in the short and long run.
Studies clearly say that more school spending means better scores and futures for students. Better spending helps kids do well in school, go to college, and make more money when they grow up. Reforms at the state level have shown this too, proving we need to put more into our schools. This should be a main goal in our policies.
Source Links
- https://www.epi.org/publication/books_teacher_quality_execsum_intro/
- https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1301471.pdf
- https://www.educationnext.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/ednext_XVI_2_goldhaber.pdf
- https://hanushek.stanford.edu/sites/default/files/publications/Hanushek+Rivkin 2006 HbEEdu 2.pdf
- https://epaa.asu.edu/index.php/epaa/article/download/392/515
- https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/33321/1001455-The-Impact-of-Teacher-Experience.PDF
- https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1216895.pdf
- https://www.itejournal.org/wp-content/pdfs-issues/fall-2012/10lineketal.pdf
- https://www.nctq.org/publications/State-of-the-States-2021:-Teacher-Preparation-Policy
- https://soeonline.american.edu/blog/5-ways-policy-makers-can-improve-the-quality-of-education/
- https://reachinghighernh.org/2024/02/27/teacher-certification-and-student-outcomes-what-the-research-says/
- https://www.nctq.org/nctq/research/1114011196655.pdf
- https://www.educationnext.org/in-schools-teacher-quality-matters-most-coleman/
- https://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1054&context=sferc
- https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED509656.pdf
- https://www.epi.org/publication/bp278/
- https://business.columbia.edu/sites/default/files-efs/pubfiles/3841/impact_rockoff.pdf
- https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/ED491674.pdf
- https://www.fcd-us.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/RootsofDecline.pdf
- https://ceds.org/school-overcrowding/
- https://www.ppic.org/publication/understanding-the-effects-of-school-funding/
- https://www.ed.gov/raisethebar/eliminating-educator-shortages-compensation-preparation-leadership